Monday, August 29, 2011

Lessons from the Law Library - The 'Answer' Does Not Exist

Last Friday on, library school intern Amanda (Andie) Bulman shared some of what she learned as a student reference assistant at the Sir James Dunn Law Library at Dalhousie University in Halifax.

She outlines 5 lessons, all of which I can identify with, but I think Lesson #2 is the most important one:
"Sometimes “The Answer” does not exist. In June slews of undergraduates were taking a business law course and came to the library on a semi-regular basis. They frequently requested my help in searching for case law or legislation that had very specific criteria and I frequently went home feeling frustrated by my inability to find 'the answer'. I eventually realized that it is unlikely that 'the answer' would be found in a single document. Legal research is a time consuming process and well-crafted legal arguments are usually constructed from a variety of resources. The answer is a myth. Legal research rarely works that way."
I helped teach an intro to legal research class last year at a local university and for me, that was the often the hardest lesson to get many of the first year students to understand (and accept).


Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 6:34 pm


Blogger John Hightower said...

Yes, sometimes the answer does not exist. Often, legal researchers are asked to prove a negative--always a difficult proposition. Westlaw Next is an extremely poor tool for doing this.

9:44 am  
Blogger Wendy Reynolds said...

Nothing is harder. It's a balancing act - have you consulted enough sources, considered enough synonyms, thought hard enough? This is particularly hard for inexperienced researchers - librarians or lawyers - when do you know that "there's nothing" is the right answer?

Unfortunately, there is also the opposite case, when a researcher looks at an online source or two and throws in the towel.

9:21 am  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home