Scottish Law Commission Discussion Paper on Civil Remedies for Domestic Abuse

The Scottish Law Commission has released a discussion paper on Civil Remedies for Domestic Abuse. It is part of a consultation process that ends in January 2025:

Many problems have been identified with current legislation on the issue:

• It is unclear how or if the law in this area interacts with criminal and child law.
• The legislation relating to the civil protection orders that can be sought in domestic abuse cases is fragmented, and the options are complicated.
• There are multiple different protective remedies available, all contained in different statutes and with different threshold tests (and there are concerns that some of the statutory tests are too high, for example for exclusion orders and powers of arrest).
• Even once a victim/survivor secures a civil protection order, there can be issues about enforcement.
• There is insufficient recognition of the impact of domestic abuse on children in the civil protection legislation.

The Discussion Paper explores many of the criticisms and considers possible changes.

It also looks at the law of civil remedies for domestic abuse in other jurisdictions, including Australia, Canada, England and Wales, Ireland, and New Zealand.