Tuesday, August 16, 2022

Congressional Research Reports on Protection of Classified Information

In the wake of last week's seizure by the F.B.I. of top secret files at the Florida residence of former U.S. President Donald Trump, the Congressional Research Service in Washington, D.C. has updated a few of its reports on the topic of classified information and presidential powers.

The New York Times also featured an article on August 14 entitled Presidential Power to Declassify Information, Explained (may require password): "Former President Donald Trump’s claim that he had declassified all of the documents that the FBI seized in the search of his Florida home last week — including those marked as top secret — has heightened interest in the scope of a president’s power to declassify information. On Friday, Trump’s office claimed that when he was president, he had a 'standing order' that materials 'removed from the Oval Office and taken to the residence were deemed to be declassified the moment he removed them,' (...) Apart from whether there is any evidence that such an order actually existed, the notion has been greeted with disdain by national security legal specialists."

And Politico on August 15 published an article entitled Why Donald Trump’s declassification claim might not be that outlandish: "Nearly 20 years ago, Justice Department prosecutors wrestled with the vexing question of whether President George W. Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney could unilaterally authorize Cheney’s chief of staff Scooter Libby to leak to select journalists the key findings of a then-highly-classified intelligence community-wide report on Iraq’s efforts to acquire weapons of mass destruction (...) One problem for Trump is that he’s no longer president and his possession of tangible copies of apparently sensitive national security records implicated a host of potential legal concerns. And, as in Libby’s case, there are other charges that could be brought against Trump besides those dealing with classified information. But the episode from the aftermath of the Iraq invasion in 2003 highlights the difficulty in pursuing prosecutions of classified information in cases that have direct links to the Oval Office."

Labels: ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 8:50 pm 0 comments

Wednesday, October 12, 2016

New Law Library of Congress Reports on Encrypted Communications and Foreign Intelligence Gathering

In Custodia Legis, the blog of the Law Library of Congress in Washington, D.C., reported earlier this week on two recent comparative law reports published by the institution.

The first, Government Access to Encrypted Communications, "describes the law of 12 nations and the European Union on whether the government, pursuant to a court order or other government process, can require companies to decrypt encrypted communications or provide the government with the means to do so".

The other one is an updated version of an earlier report entitled Foreign Intelligence Gathering Laws that examines the legislation regulating the collection of intelligence in the European Union (EU) and Belgium, France, Germany, Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Sweden, and the United Kingdom..

The Law Library of Congress is the world’s largest law library, with a collection of over 2.65 million volumes from all ages of history and virtually every jurisdiction in the world.

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 9:17 pm 0 comments

Monday, December 14, 2015

New Zealand Law Commission Releases Reports on Victims of Sexual Violence and on Protection of Sensitive Information

The New Zealand Law Commission today released two reports.

The first is The Crown in Court: A review of the Crown Proceedings Act and national security information in proceedings. It has two parts: 
  •  Part 1, A new Crown Civil Proceedings Act, recommends replacing the Crown Proceedings Act 1950 with new legislation that enables people to seek effective legal redress when the Crown has breached a legal obligation.
  • Part 2, National security information in proceedings, makes recommendations around how information that might pose a threat to national security if released to the public should be dealt with in court proceedings. 
The second report is The Justice Response to Victims of Sexual Violence: Criminal Trials and Alternative Processes. It considers whether a non-criminal process is a viable alternative way of dealing with certain incidents of sexual violence, where that is desired by the victim, and puts forward a proposal to give effect to such an alternative.

Among other elements, the report proposes that:
  • All judges who sit on sexual violence trials should receive special training
  • A specialist sexual violence court should be piloted and future consideration should be given to whether proceedings in that court should or should not be heard in front of a jury.
  • Government should put in place a legal and policy framework to give effect to an alternative process that could operate entirely separately of criminal trial.
  • The process would provide for a victim to complete a programme that addresses the harm caused by the sexual violence and that facilitates discussion with and reparation by the perpetrator, if appropriate.

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 6:55 pm 0 comments

Tuesday, April 14, 2015

Article on University of Toronto's Searchable Database of Edward Snowden Documents

This is a follow-up to the Library Boy post of March 6, 2015 entitled Canadians Create New Searchable Database of Edward Snowden Documents.

U of T News,  the news website of the University of Toronto, published an article yesterday about the Snowden Surveillance Archive, a database of all the publicly released classified documents leaked by former U.S. National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden.

The Archive project was led by the university's Andrew Clement, a professor at the institution's "iSchool" (information studies):
"Launched in partnership with the Canadian Journalists for Free Expression, the archive is just one part of an international effort led by the iSchool's Clement to develop constructive responses by iSchools around the world to the growing challenge of mass state surveillance."

"A public statement endorsed by Clement and faculty at iSchools across North America calls for universities to: develop curriculum that addresses issues of mass state surveillance and prepare students to understand better the surveillance to which they are exposed; invite NSA and other government officials as guest course speakers to address issues of mass state surveillance and respond to student questions; and invite NSA whistleblowers and journalists who have covered the NSA disclosures as guest speakers to address issues of mass state surveillance and respond to student questions."


Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 7:37 pm 0 comments

Friday, March 06, 2015

Canadians Create New Searchable Database of Edward Snowden Documents

George Raine, a recent graduate of the Faculty of Information’s Master of Information program at the University of Toronto, has created the Snowden Surveillance Archive, a searchable database of all the publicly released classified documents leaked by former U.S. National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden.
 
The leaks reveal the widespread surveillance practices by security and espionage agencies in the US and allied countries.

Archive project partners are Canadian Journalists for Free Expression and the Politics of Surveillance Project at University of Toronto’s Faculty of Information. Funding came from The New Transparency: Surveillance and Social Sorting, a seven-year Major Collaborative Research Initiative funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council.

There are currently close to 400 documents in the Archive. The Archive website explains that these are “a small fraction of the estimated 50,000 documents Snowden turned over. Most of these will likely not be published, but as new documents are published, they will be added to the Archive.”
It is possible to search by program name, target, agency, classification and ordinary keyword.

Other groups such as the American Civil Liberties Union have released files that Snowden leaked to journalists in June 2013 but the Snowden Surveillance Archive claims it is the world’s first fully indexed and searchable collection of the files.

Many of the documents have been published by The Guardian, The New York Times, The Washington Post, Der Spiegel, Le Monde, El Mundo and The Intercept. In this country, the CBC has been shedding light on Canada-related files leaked by Snowden.

[Cross-posted to Slaw.ca]

Labels: , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 4:48 pm 0 comments

Thursday, July 11, 2013

Wave of Legal Challenges to NSA Electronic Surveillance

The revelations by U.S. whistleblower Edward Snowden that the National Security Agency has been conducting widespread snooping against pretty much everyone, everywhere, all the time has provoked more than just political and diplomatic fallout.

As can be expected, there are several new lawsuits.

The American non-profit investigative journalism website Pro Publica has created the NSA Surveillance Lawsuit Tracker that lists the "key legal challenges to [U.S.] government surveillance and secrecy" since 2006. The last lawsuit added to the list was filed on July 8th.
For a Canadian take on government whistleblowers, I recommend the work of the NGO FAIR (Federal Accountability Initiative for Reform).

FAIR produces a monthly newsletter, the most recent issue being from June 2013. One of the articles is Canada slow to protect whistleblowing spies, soldiers.

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 5:57 pm 0 comments

Thursday, October 04, 2012

U.S. National Security Archive Guest Blogs on Free Government Information Blog

The U.S.-based blog Free Government Information was launched a few years ago by a group of academic librarians who wanted to raise public awareness of the importance of better access to all forms of government information.

They occasionally have guest bloggers and this month's guest will be a real treat for history buffs, archive geeks, hard core freedom of information fans and investigative reporter types: Malcolm Byrne from the National Security Archive, a non-governmental organization based at George Washington University that specializes in declassified documents. His first post is about the Archive's work on the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis:
"For anyone who loves anniversaries, this month is a biggie. Fifty years ago the world survived one of the seminal events of the nuclear age -- the Cuban missile crisis. I mention it because almost from the very start, the National Security Archive’s been an active promoter of studying the crisis (we’ll have a series of postings of the latest findings on our site in the coming weeks), and it makes for a good case study of what our organization’s mission is and how we go about our work (...)"

"The Cuban missile crisis project in many ways became a model for our other historical documentation projects at the National Security Archive, including studies of U.S. policy toward the Vietnam War, the Soviet Union and the superpower rivalry, a series of crises in Eastern Europe during the Cold War, and more. Most of the basic stories of these projects are available on our site and, as mentioned, the underlying documentation we and our partners and colleagues around the world have collected is also available here in Washington, D.C."
The National Security Archive was founded in 1985 by journalists and scholars and it combines the activities of an investigative journalism centre, a research institute on international affairs, and a library with a massive collection of declassified U.S. documents.

It has launched access to information lawsuits against the U.S. government, many of which have been successful, forcing the declassification of documents such as the Kennedy-Khrushchev letters during the Cuban Missile Crisis, previously censored photographs of flag-draped coffins of U.S. casualties from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan being unloaded at night at airforce bases, and documents that led to the conviction of a ranking military officer on human rights abuse charges in Guatemala.

Staff members and fellows have written over 60 books, many of which have won prizes including the Pulitzer Prize and the U.S. National Book Award.

Its website hosts more than one million pages of previously censored or secret government documents and constitutes one of the largest and most complete online archives of contemporary history.

It is based at George Washington University's Gelman Library. It receives no funding from government sources.

[Cross-posted to Slaw.ca]

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 6:02 pm 0 comments

Sunday, December 05, 2010

New Search Engine For Wikileaks State Department Cables

This is a follow-up to the Library Boy post of December 2, 2010 entitled For Wikileaks Geeks: How to Decipher a State Department Cable.

The Vereniging van Onderzoeksjournalisten (Dutch-Flemish Association of Investigative Journalists) has launched CableSearch, a tool that allows users to search the full text of the confidential American diplomatic cables being released by the whistleblower organization WikiLeaks.

Users can also browse cables using the following categories:

+ Zeitgeist (Real-Time Look at What Others Are Searching For)
+ New Cables
+ Most Popular
+ By Source
+ By Classification
+ By Urgency
+ By Tag
+ By Date

[Source: ResourceShelf]

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 5:10 pm 0 comments

Thursday, December 02, 2010

For Wikileaks Geeks: How to Decipher a State Department Cable

The National Security Archive, based at George Washington University, has provided a guide explaining How to Decipher a State Department Cable:
"This guide ... might come in handy as you peruse the 251,287 Department of State cables recently released by wikileaks (...)"

"At the Archive, we have lots of practice reading declassified government documents. Since we will be using this space to share with you some documents from our trove of government releases, we thought it would be useful to give you some tips on what to look for in these documents. Several of our experienced analysts have created a series of 'cheat sheets' for different types of agency records."
The Archive collects and publishes declassified documents obtained through the Freedom of Information Act in the USA. The Archive also serves as a repository of government records on topics pertaining to the national security, foreign, intelligence, and economic policies of the United States.

The Archive has won lawsuits to bring into the public domain confidential materials on the Cuban Missile Crisis, the Iran-Contra Affair and other historical controversies.

It receives funding from the Carnegie Corporation of New York, the Ford Foundation, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, and the Open Society Institute.

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 8:14 pm 0 comments

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Australian Law Reform Commission Releases Final Report on Government Secrecy

The Australian Law Reform Commission today tabled its final report on Commonwealth secrecy laws in the Australian Parliament.

Entitled Secrecy Laws and Open Government in Australia, the report identified 506 secrecy provisions in 176 pieces of Commonwealth legislation, including 358 criminal secrecy offences. Many of the secrecy provisions were found to have a catch-all nature and to over-rely on criminal sanctions.

The Commission recommends that administrative and disciplinary frameworks should play the central role in ensuring that government information is handled appropriately. Criminal sanctions should only be imposed when disclosure of government information is likely to cause harm.

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 6:55 pm 0 comments

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Australian Law Reform Commission Review of Secrecy Laws

The Australian Law Reform Commission has released a consultation paper on Secrecy Laws.

In the accompanying press release, the Commission President David Weisbrot is quoted as saying:

"The federal statute book has become riddled with secrecy provisions, which make unauthorised disclosure of government information a criminal offence. So far the ALRC has identified over 370 distinct secrecy provisions scattered across 166 pieces of legislation—many more than we expected to find. "

"Some of these laws relate to matters of national security or other classified or sensitive information, and seem appropriate. However, we're less sure about the need for secrecy provisions in such laws as the Dental Benefits Act, the Dairy Produce Act or the Port Statistics Act. "

"A threshold question is whether we should ever charge someone with a crime for disclosing information that a citizen has the right to obtain under Freedom of Information laws? And how do we reconcile the increasing need of public officials to share information with each other and with the private sector to tackle the big issues facing us, such as terrorism, climate change and dealing with the global financial crisis?"

"We seem to be caught in a time warp, between an old culture of secrecy in government and more modern ideas about the fundamental importance to democracy of ensuring openness and accountability."

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 5:14 pm 0 comments

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

U.S. Government Secrecy Continues To Rise

According to the Secrecy Report Card 2008 of the U.S. advocacy group OpenTheGovernment.org, U.S. government secrecy continued to rise in 2007.

It is the organization's fifth annual report assessing trends in public access to information in that Great Republic to the South.

A representative of the American Association of Law Libraries sits on the steering committee of the watchdog group that fights to push back government secrecy.

Among the highlights:
  • The American government spent $195 maintaining the secrets already on the books for every one dollar the government spent declassifying documents in 2007, a 5% increase in one year. At the same time, fewer pages were declassified than in 2006, even though the government spent the same amount of money on declassification. The intelligence agencies, which account for a large segment of the declassification numbers, are excluded from the total reported figures.
  • The total cost of Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) implementation in 2007 across the government increased 16%. But a 2008 study by the Coalition of Journalists for Open Government (CJOG) revealed that, in 2007, FOIA spending at the 25 agencies it examined fell by $7 million to $233.8 million and the agencies put 209 fewer people to work processing FOIA requests.
  • Almost 22 million FOIA requests were received in 2007, an increase of almost 2% over last year. Agencies are not, however, taking advantage of significant opportunities to reduce their backlogs: the 25 departments and agencies that handle the bulk of the third-party information requests received the fewest requests since reporting began in 1998 — 63,000 fewer than 2006 — but they processed only 2,100 more requests than they did in 2006 (when the backlog soared to a record 39%).
  • On average since 2000, non-competed contract funding makes up more than 25 percent of all awards. In FY 2007, 26.15 percent ($114.1 billion) of federal contract funding was given out without any competition; another 5 percent ($22.9 billion) was awarded without competition because of specific requirements. In 2000, 45 percent of contract dollars were awarded under full and open competition; by 2007, only 33 percent followed such open procedures — a drop of almost 25%.
  • With 2,371 secret surveillance orders approved in 2007, federal surveillance activity under the jurisdiction of the secretive Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court has risen for the 9th year in a row — more than doubling since 2000.
The report isn't entirely pessimistic, noting some progress in the U.S. Congress where many legislative proposals have been introduced to protect whistleblowers, increase transparency and accountability in federal spending, reduce overclassification of government information, and limit the use of the state secrets privilege.

Related Library Boy posts about Canadian government secrecy include:
  • Freedom of Information: Code of Silence 2006 Award Nominees (May 11, 2006): "The Canadian Association of Journalists has released the list of nominees for its sixth annual Code of Silence Award recognizing the most secretive government agency in Canada (...)."
  • Many Federal Departments Flunk in 2006-2007 Information Commissioner Report Card (May 30, 2007): "In his first annual report, the new federal Information Commissioner Robert Marleau concludes that a great many Canadian government agencies show a serious lack of transparency when it comes to access to government documents under the Access to Information Act : 'Despite much progress since 1983, there remain impediments to the full realization of Parliament’s intent as expressed in the Act. Too often, responses to access requests are late, incomplete, or overly-censored. Too often, access is denied to hide wrongdoing, or to protect officials or governments from embarrassment, rather than to serve a legitimate confidentiality requirement. Year after year, in the pages of these reports, information commissioners recount what is going wrong and offer views on how to make it right'."
  • Media Reports Government Wants to Can Access to Information Database (May 3, 2008): "The Toronto Star is reporting that the federal government is putting an end to the Coordination of Access to Information Requests System (CAIRS), an internal database of every request filed to all federal departments and agencies under the Access to Information Act (ATIA) ... CAIRS was seen by lawyers, reporters, and government watchdog groups as a very useful resource. They could mine the information in the database, approach government departments and request copies of already released documents."

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 6:08 pm 0 comments

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Law Library of Congress World Law Bulletin 2000-2006 Now Online

The 2000-2006 issues of the World Law Bulletin, a publication of the Law Library of Congress in the U.S., have been posted on the Internet.

On the site of the Federation of American Scientists Project on Government Secrecy!

"The WORLD LAW BULLETIN is a monthly publication of the Directorate of Legal Research at the Law Library of Congress.

The Bulletin, which is distributed to members of Congress and staff but not the public, provides updates on foreign law developments".

"In May 2006, the Law Library began publishing the Global Legal Monitor, which partially replicates the contents of the World Law Bulletin in publicly releasable form".

[Source Barclay Blog, Syracuse University College of Law]

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 3:17 pm 0 comments

Thursday, May 10, 2007

CALL Conference 2007 - Press Bans, Privacy and Access to Information

The Tuesday plenary session at this year's annual conference of the Canadian Association of Law Libraries in Ottawa was a panel discussion entitled "Are We Becoming a Secret Society? Press Bans, Privacy and Access to Information".

The speakers were Barbara McIsaac, senior counsel, McCarthy Tétrault LLP, Ottawa; John Reid, former Information Commissioner of Canada; and Rick Dearden, of Gowlings Lafleur Henderson LLP Ottawa.

McIsaac is co-author of The Law of Privacy in Canada, one of the major Canadian privacy law texts. She served as Senior Counsel to the Somalia Inquiry and Senior Counsel for the Government of Canada to the Arar Inquiry. She has also represented the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation in front of the Cornwall Inquiry on the investigation of an alleged pedophile ring in Eastern Ontario.

McIsaac, who has been on both sides of the fence when it comes to access to official government information, made one essential point throughout her presentation that touched on the many dimensions of the conflict between the public's right to know, legitimate state interests to protect government sources in national security affairs, and the strong interest of private individuals to protect their reputations when they have never been charged or have had criminal charges dropped against them. That point was the natural tendency of bureaucracies to "overclaim" state interests in withholding information.

Dearden also made that same point. And he feels that things have been getting worse since the September 11 terrorist attacks.

Over the years, Dearden has argued media law cases before every level of court in Ontario, the Federal Court of Canada, the Federal Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court of Canada. He also acted for the Office of the Auditor General throughout the hearings of the Commission of Inquiry Into The Sponsorship Program and Advertising Activities (Gomery Inquiry).

He most recently represented Ottawa Citizen reporter Juliet O'Neill, whose home and office were raided by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police in 2004 as part of an investigation into leaks of classified information about Maher Arar, the Syrian-born Canadian who was deported to Syria by the United States, suspected of ties to al Qaeda. Arar, of course, was tortured in Syria before being returned to Canada. A judicial commission, the Arar Inquiry under Justice O'Connor, cleared Arar of any taint of association with terrorism.

The sealed search warrants against Ms. O'Neill were executed under the Security of Information Act, which is normally intended to protect sensitive state or defence information from spies and traitors. Lawyers representing Ms. O'Neill and the newspaper launched a legal action to have the search warrants declared unconstitutional and quashed, and for police to return all items seized during the raids, including Ms. O'Neill's notebooks and computer files. The sections of the legislation under which the warrants were executed were struck down for arbitrariness and their unconstitutional vagueness. O'Neill could have faced up to 14 years in prison under the section of the Act that was declared to be in violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Like McIsaac, Dearden described what he sees as a government pattern to "overclaim" national security or secrecy interests. Often, officials made the broadest possible claims about the need to protect as much information as possible as an opening negotiating position and then unseal documents only if ordered to do so by a court of law. He argues that this belittles genuine national security interests that truly protect the public, as opposed to protecting the government from embarrassing leaks and revelations.

Former Information Commissioner John Reid, whose job for 8 years was to see to the application of the federal Access to Information Act, explained some of his powers under that legislation. For instance, he could take government departments to court on behalf of freedom of information requestors. Of course, he was also often sued back by officials seeking to prevent the release of information felt to be sensitive or injurious to government interests under various exceptions defined under the Act.

He explained that his record in front of the courts was excellent: according to Reid, he won 100% of the cases he initiated, and 94% of the cases when he was being sued by the federal government. His conclusion: the government obviously knew this. Which leads him to believe the government was using the court system to delay release of information to the point that any timeliness for the requestor practically disappeared.

Again, in the case of access to federal government information, the same pattern referred to by McIsaac and Dearden applied: overclaiming the need to protect.

Nonetheless, Reid stressed to the audience that the importance of the Access to Information Act could not be underestimated.

It is after all through the use of the legislation that the public discovered recently how Taliban fighters captured by Canadian troops in Afghanistan were being turned over to Afghan security officials despite reports from Canadian diplomats about the risk of mistreatment and possibly torture. As well, Maher Arar was able, through the Act, to get bits and pieces of information that ultimately, along with other information, helped show that he was a man innocent of any wrongdoing or connection to terrorist activity.

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 5:25 pm 0 comments

Saturday, July 01, 2006

Recent Library of Parliament Publications on Access to Information

I happen to be browsing through Blacked Out : Government Secrecy in the Information Age, a book by Syracuse University professor Alaisdair Roberts.

The book refers quite frequently to Canada's Access to Information Act, which has been the object of many proposals for reform in recent years.

The Library of Parliament has published a number of studies on the topic recently:
  • The Access to Information Act and Recent Proposals for Reform (February 6, 2006): "It is widely agreed that, after more than 20 years in operation, the Access to Information Act should be updated. The Conservative, New Democratic and Bloc Québécois parties all included access to information reform in their platforms for the 2006 election. The legislation is recognized as a critical element of the transparency and openness in government that is necessary to the proper functioning of Canada’s parliamentary democracy. Justice John Gomery, in the Phase 2 report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Sponsorship Program and Advertising Activities, Restoring Accountability, acknowledged the importance of the legislation, saying that 'an appropriate access to information regime is a key part of the transparency that is an essential element of modern public administration'. The Act has been reviewed many times since its inception, giving rise to a significant accumulation of reform proposals. This paper identifies the key points emerging from the major studies of the Act that have been conducted over the last two decades, and analyzes in some detail the most recent proposals concerning the legislation."
  • Access to Information Legislation in Canada and Four Other Countries (April 6, 2006): "This paper briefly considers the freedom of information statutes in place in four other jurisdictions: the United Kingdom, Ireland, Australia and New Zealand. These countries were selected for comparison because they were identified in then-Justice Minister Irwin Cotler’s April 2005 document entitled A Comprehensive Framework for Access to Information Reform: A Discussion Paper as being those which might be most appropriately considered in preparing for reform of the ATIA. These countries’ access to information schemes are useful for the purpose of comparison with Canada’s because all four countries have Westminster-style parliamentary systems, and their access regimes have been developed at varying points during the ATIA’s 23-year history."
  • Bill C-2: The Federal Accountability Act - Legislative Summary (April 21, 2006): "Bill C-2, An Act providing for conflict of interest rules, restrictions on election financing and measures respecting administrative transparency, oversight and accountability (the Federal Accountability Act) was given first reading in the House of Commons on 11 April 2006. The bill makes a series of amendments to existing legislation and proposes two new Acts, in diverse areas that are generally linked to political accountability. (...) Amendments to the Access to Information Act extend its application to 15 Officers of Parliament, Crown corporations and foundations, and also establish new exemptions or exclusions relating to the added entities." [Note: the progress of Bill C-2 can be followed using the Library of Parliament's LEGISinfo service]

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 8:01 pm 0 comments

Monday, March 14, 2005

U.S. media hold Sunshine Week to protest clampdown on access to government info

This week marks "Sunshine Week" for our neighbours to the South. As one organizer explained:

"(N)ever has freedom of information been under greater siege. The open hostility to FOI flows from Washington and the Department of Justice. The actions in our nation's capital are mimicked more and more on a state and local level."

According to an article in Sunday's Guardian (UK) newspaper, "In addition to decreasing some types of information released under FOIA, the federal government is increasing the number of documents deemed secret and has pulled thousands of documents and databases off public Web sites... Since Sept. 11, 2001, at least 20 states have proposed new laws to control public records, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures...A new state-by-state study of public records laws by the Better Government Association concluded that the array of legislation is so haphazard that it hampers 'the citizenry's ability to examine even the most fundamental actions of government'."

In parallel, an American student organization, FreeCulture.org, organized BlogShine Sunday to encourage bloggers throughout the U.S. and beyond to spotlight their own experiences with obtaining access to government documents.

You can find a roundup of media coverage on the Sunshine Week web site.

Labels: ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 7:16 pm 0 comments

Friday, March 04, 2005

Things You're Not Supposed to Know

One of my longstanding interests is access to government information or "freedom of information" issues as they get called in the United States.

I love this tool: http://track.foi.net is a searchable database of requests for information submitted to federal institutions under Canada's Access to Information Act (ATIA). It is a creation of Alasdair Roberts, a professor at the Campbell Public Affairs Institute, Maxwell School, Syracuse University. He is a Canadian who used to teach at the School of Policy Studies at Queen's University.

Roberts produces an AMBERLIGHT MONITOR, for example, here's the January 2005 edition. ATIA requests submitted by journalists and Members of Parliament are tagged by federal agencies for "special attention", which may cause delay in the processing of requests. In some agencies, these requests are said to be "amberlighted." The amberlighted requests deal with issues we are not supposed to find out about too quickly - but if you track them, you might be able to guess what will be appearing on the front page of your newspaper some time soon.

There was a time perhaps 10 or 15 years ago when one could feel that government secretiveness was gradually being eroded thanks to better access legislation. Are we regressing? Amberlighting seems to be part of a trend to restrain or even block public access.

In late 2003, the Toronto Star published a lengthy series that concluded that "the public's right to access government information is often subverted, delayed and denied by politicians and their advisers".

Not a good sign.

There are some interesting US sites that deal with the damage to freedom of information down there under the Bush administration. For the truly nosy among you, I would recommend Memory Hole, the National Security Archives and the Project on Government Secrecy.

The Memory Hole collects and publishes elusive records and documents that have been withdrawn from the public domain. It also features a blog and an XML-based news feed.

The National Security Archives is funded by the Carnegie Corporation, the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation and the Ford Foundation. The Archives are "simultaneously a research institute on international affairs, a library and archive of declassified U.S. documents obtained through the Freedom of Information Act, a public interest law firm defending and expanding public access to government information through the FOIA, and an indexer and publisher of the documents in books, microfiche, and electronic formats."

The Project on Government Secrecy is run by the Federation of American Scientists.

Labels: ,

Bookmark and Share Subscribe
posted by Michel-Adrien at 1:08 pm 0 comments